The UK Government may be encouraging greenwash
in its announcement on 'hydrogen ready' boilers

Dave Toke's green energy blog - Saturday, 4 January 2020

The Government's announcement that from 2025 gas boilers will have to be 'hydrogen ready' could presage the start of one of the greatest pieces of greenwash that have been committed in the UK. It seems likely to result in carbon emissions being substantially increased, compared to the present use of natural gas in boilers to heat homes.

David Toke

The oil and gas industry is promoting so-called 'blue hydrogen', that is hydrogen produced by 'reforming' natural gas, and capturing the carbon dioxide that is produced.

Yet currently most hydrogen is produced by reforming natural gas and not capturing carbon dioxide, a process that will dramatically increase carbon dioxide emissions if hydrogen is used to heat homes. The efficiency of the gas reformation process is only around 65%, meaning that much more carbon dioxide is generated to produce the hydrogen as fuel compared to simply burning the natural gas. Any claims that the process will be done using carbon capture and storage, beyond the few demonstration projects supported by public grants, should be taken with a wagon load of salt.

Grossly inefficient use of renewable energy

But the sad thing is that even if 'green hydrogen' for heating homes was to be generated by renewable energy (through electrolysis of water) it would still be a grossly inefficient way of using that renewable energy. Renewable energy is normally distributed through the electricity system where it can power heat pumps in homes (either individually or through district heating systems) to much much greater effect.

The heat pumps use electricity much more efficiently compared to any hydrogen boilers, no matter how the hydrogen is produced. Indeed a heat pump may increase the efficiency of the use of renewable energy by approaching fourfold compared to burning 'green hydrogen' in a boiler.

Not only does the heat pump multiply the heat from the electricity by around threefold (by drawing heat from the surrounding environment) but it avoids losing energy through electrolysis.

So, in terms of reducing carbon emissions we will need FOUR times the amount of renewable energy to produce the same heating effect in buildings if we were to turn it into hydrogen – compared to using the renewable energy delivered through the electricity system to transfer heat using heat pumps.

So the Government should be looking at ways to ensure heat pumps are used as a rule in new buildings and giving incentives to have existing buildings retrofitted with heat pumps. This is as opposed to being hijacked by the oil and gas lobby to pass off business as usual under a greenwashed cover story.


See Renewable Heating          See Renewable Cooling